Français English

A deceptive phenomenon

Send to a friend Print

There are many misconceptions about weightlessness. Here are 3 of the most common:

Misconception number 1:
“Weightlessness is caused by a vacuum”.
Imagined by Jean-Pierre Penot (CNES) and Bernard Nicolas, illustrated by Bernard Nicolas

Imagined by Jean-Pierre Penot (CNES) and Bernard Nicolas, illustrated by Bernard Nicolas

It is often wrongly assumed that someone’s weight is due to air pressure bearing down on their shoulders. But the weight of an object measured in a vacuum only varies by 1‰ from its weight in the open air.
To prove it, consider an astronaut on the Moon: s/he is in the vacuum of space but gravity is still present, albeit weaker than on Earth.
Conversely, astronauts in a space station are in weightless conditions but not in a vacuum, otherwise they would be unable to breathe.



Misconception number 2:
“Weightlessness is caused by the distance from Earth”. At 400 kilometres above Earth, where orbital stations like Mir or the International Space Station operate, astronauts are in weightlessness although gravitational attraction is only 10% less than on the Earth’s surface. Gravity lessens as we get further away from Earth, but we would need to travel hundreds of millions of kilometres to free ourselves from it out completely.

Misconception number 3:
“We are in a state of weightlessness in water:”
Illustrated by Jean-Pierre Penot (CNES) and Bernard Nicolas, illustrated by Bernard Nicolas

Illustrated by Jean-Pierre Penot (CNES) and Bernard Nicolas, illustrated by Bernard Nicolas

Even though our body may seem very light and agile in water, its weight has not disappeared. Our weight is offset by the water in contact with the whole of our body, whereas normally it is only offset at the point in contact with the ground (most often our feet). The force that creates this impression of being light in the water is in fact what we call buoyancy.



 
 
Did you know?
Archimedes’ principle
“Any body submerged in a fluid is acted upon by an upward, or buoyant, force equal to the weight of the fluid it displaces”. This physical law of buoyancy was discovered by the ancient Greek mathematician and inventor Archimedes (287 – 212 B.C.). According to legend, he made the discovery in his bath, whereupon he leapt out and ran into the street shouting “Eureka!” (“I have found it!” ). Archimedes was a supreme scholar who formulated many theories and is also credited with inventing the screw.

 



 

 
Top